A Pike County woman whose daughter was molested in 1998 contends she did not

approve of the sentence handed down in the case by Superior Court Judge Johnnie

L. Caldwell Jr., which the judge indicated at a press conference last week.

Last week, Caldwell defended

the sentencing of Ben Hunton of Meansville, who pled guilty to the

reduced charge of enticing a child for indecent purposes

because the case file from the Pike County Sheriff's Office was missing,

the judge said. Caldwell noted that the victim and her family requested the

10-year probation sentence and first offender treatment Hunton received.

But the victim's mother

said Friday that she did not request that sentence and she had no idea

Hunton was sentenced under the first offender act until

the sentence was handed down in court.

During the sentencing hearing, Caldwell was told by assistant district attorney

Gail Travillian that the victim and her family were made aware of what was

to transpire at the hearing.

Caldwell declined to comment for this article.

The case was brought back into the public spotlight after a political mailing

Court judgeship. The oversized postcard referred to six news articles, including

one about the Hunton case, and Mrosek asked voters to examine the articles

and the court documents on each case and make up their own mind.

The victim's mother is particularly upset that Hunton is not on the state's

sex offender registry.

"We wanted other people to know what he had done," the victim's

mother said.

Hunton was not required to register as a sex offender because the offense

of enticing a child for indecent purposes is not one of those where registering

for the statewide list is required.

As a first offender, Hunton's

criminal record will be cleared of the charge if he successfully completes

his probation. If Hunton is charged with

another crime, however, Caldwell could revoke the probation and force him to

serve the remainder of his sentence in prison.

"That first offender doesn't mean this is the first time he did

it," the victim's mother said. "It's just the first time

he was caught."

The victim's mother did

not protest the sentence, according to the transcript of the hearing.

The victim no longer lives in the area although her parents still do.

The victim's mother said Travillian had said she couldn't do anything

with the case after the file went missing from the Pike County Sheriff's

Department.

Hunton received a 10-year probation sentence in addition to a $1,500 fine

and payment of more than $10,000 for medical and counseling expenses.

Caldwell said the investigative

case file compiled by the Pike County Sheriff's

Department has not been found since the case; had it not disappeared, Hunton

would likely have faced prison time if found guilty, Caldwell said.

"It's not all about the money," the victim's mother said. "No

amount of money could ever replace what was taken from that child."

Court documents also show

that Travillian filed a motion to revoke Hunton's

bond before the case was scheduled to go to trial. Prosecutors alleged that

Hunton followed the victim on May 15, 2001, and appeared at her place of employment

July 10, 2001, "for purposes of harassing and intimidating said victim."

Mrosek told The Citizen last

week that the cases show Caldwell is soft on child molestation cases.

All but one of the five cases called into question

involved offenders receiving probation, but Caldwell said that was because

prosecutors felt they didn't have enough evidence to secure convictions.

Home | News | Sports | Opinion | Weekend | Special Sections | Classifieds | Archives

Copyright 2004-Fayette Publishing, Inc.