The lawsuit challenging Peachtree
City's Big Box ordinance was delayed Tuesday after all parties agreed
to give the city council a chance to vote on a site plan for an expansion
of the Kedron Village shopping center that includes a 125,000 sq. ft.
Target store.
The Big Box ordinance limits
retail stores to a maximum size of 32,000 sq. ft. except under special
circumstances.
The site plan will be placed
on the agenda for the city council's March 4 meeting and all parties
will be prepared to argue the case in court March 8 if necessary.
The site plan was denied by
the city's planning commission in October, but instead of appealing
the matter to the city council, developers Peachtree City Holdings and
FCD Development filed the suit in court.
Arguments in the lawsuit were
scheduled to begin Tuesday morning, but attorneys for the Lake Kedron
Community Association sought a dismissal of the case because the City
Council had not yet voted on the site plan.
Georgia law requires that all
administrative remedies be exhausted before such suits can be brought.
Because the developers declined to appeal the planning commission's
decision to the city council, the final administrative remedy hasn't
been exhausted, association attorneys argued.
Originally, attorneys for the
city and the developers agreed to waive that requirement, but Superior
Court Judge Christopher C. Edwards said he wasn't sure that was legally
possible.
After hearing arguments from
all parties on the issue, Edwards brokered an agreement to let the city
council get one more shot at voting on the site plan, which previously
was denied by the city's planning commission.
"I think there ought to
be a vote over there," Edwards said, adding that he cannot require
the City Council to vote on the Target plan. Edwards said having the matter
on a City Council agenda also gives homeowners opposed to the plan a chance
to intervene at the legislative level with the council before the matter
is taken to court.
The suit challenges the application
of the Big Box ordinance to the Kedron Village retail center since the
ordinance specifically applies to tenants and in this case Target would
actually own the building. The city contends its definition of tenants
includes any business occupying a building whether the building is leased
or purchased.
Attorneys for Peachtree City
Holdings and FCD Development have also argued that the site has an exemption
to the Big Box ordinance via a letter signed by former Peachtree City
Mayor Bob Lenox. The city contends that alleged exemption is not valid.
The developers also asked the
court to sanction the use of Georgian Terrace Parkway as an access road
for the new stores, but in court documents the city stipulated that would
be allowable, rendering the issue moot.







Easy button Return it to long suffering taxpayers including those who have paid huge tabs to educate other people's kids…