James Lamar Watson Jr., convicted
of murdering his wife in 1997 and dumping her body in a wooded area of
south Fulton County, will not be getting a new trial.
The Fulton County judge who
ruled over the case, T. Jackson Bedford Jr., has denied Watson's
motion for a new trial in a 12-page order filed late Tuesday afternoon.
Watson's lead defense
attorney, Lee Sexton, said Wednesday that he will file a notice of appeal
with the Georgia Supreme Court as early as today.
"We're very confident
the Supreme Court will not let that conviction stand," largely due
to the amount of judicial error alleged by defense attorneys, Sexton said.
Watson, who claimed his wife
Beverley disappeared from their south Fayette home after a heated argument
between the two Jan. 17, 1997, will remain in the Fulton County jail pending
further appeal of his case. He is there instead of the state corrections
system because his attorneys want him close by to help with the appeal
process, Sexton said.
Watson testified at trial and
maintained his innocence.
Watson was sentenced to life
in prison immediately after the verdict was read in June 2002.
Watson's attorneys used
19 different claims asserting he should get a new trial, and Judge Bedford
addressed some of those claims in detail while denying others with little
comment.
Defense attorneys were particularly
hopeful about their challenge of the indictment, which was ultimately
denied. Specifically, they pointed out that the assistant district attorney
argued in her closing that Jim Watson killed Beverley Watson at their
Fayette home before dumping it in Fulton County.
But that claim could not be
considered by the jury as evidence, Bedford noted.
"The evidence presented
could have equally supported the conclusion that the defendant somehow
was able to bring the victim to Fulton County prior to death (maybe while
she was incapacitated) and inflict a mortal wound in this county,"
Bedford wrote.
Watson's defense team
also complained several comments the judge made in front of the jury during
the trial were prejudicial against Watson, but the judge ruled that some
of those comments were "initiated and invited" by defense counsel
and indicated that another comment attorneys complained about was obviously
made in jest during a humorous moment of the trial.
Watson was convicted with little
physical evidence, save for scratches on his face which he tried to cover
up with makeup before he called the Fayette County Sheriff's Department
to report his wife missing two days after her disappearance.
Lt. Col. Bruce Jordan of the
Fayette County Sheriff's Department first noticed the scratches when
a TV news crew's bright lights shone on Watson's face.
Fulton County Assistant District
Attorney Sheila Ross used photos of those scratches in her closing argument,
urging that Beverley Watson used her fingernails to "mark her killer."
Jim Watson testified on the
stand that the couple indeed argued that night and that the scratches
on his face likely occurred when she threw keys at him.
Watson's attorneys also
complained that they were ordered not to air TV footage and a taped interview
with a Fulton County detective during which Watson proclaims his innocence.
Bedford also ruled the court did not err in forbidding that content from
being played to the jury .







Easy button Return it to long suffering taxpayers including those who have paid huge tabs to educate other people's kids…