FY 2002
Audit Recommendations
The accounting
firm Mauldin & Jenkins made the following recommendation in the Audit
for the year ending September 30, 2002:
"During
our audit for the year ending September 30, 2002, we noted that key members
of management did not contain an adequate level of knowledge and control
over the accounting function. We encountered several examples of this
throughout the audit, including not being furnished with amounts owed
was complete. Management should take more of a role in the accounting
function of the Authority and obtain the knowledge necessary to make management
decisions."
Individual
Authority members have worked diligently with staff on this issue even
helping re-format the budget report; however, much of the information
received by the Authority is still vague and it is difficult for members
to have confidence in the financial picture as presented. (See Exhibit
B)
Cash flow
problems
The DAPC sent
approximately $130,000 more than it received from all revenue sources
in FY 2002. The Authority passed a balanced budget for FY 2003 based on
the expectation that the share of the Hotel-Motel tax would be reduced.
Conservative revenue estimates from the two event facilities were also
used in the development of the budget. The city did not reduce the DAPC
share of the Hotel-Motel tax. This fact combined with increased ticket
prices at the Amphitheater, led me to believe the DAPC would operate within
the FY2003 budget. We received highly optimistic financial reports throughout
the year and I was stunned to learn on September 15, two weeks before
the end of the fiscal year, of serious cash flow problems. It was clear
from the information provided that the DAPC would have difficulty meeting
the final payroll ($36,000) and paying the band ($50,000) for the last
performance of the concert series on September 26 and 27. Three Authority
members have been placed in the untenable position of meeting with staff
to resolve this problem. The best action seems to be to defer payments
to vendors, which in some cases are past due, and "hold" checks
that are already written but have not been mailed. Borrowing is not an
option because of our commitment to City Council not to borrow funds.
Unfortunately, the necessary deferrals of major financial obligations
will contribute to even more severe cash flow problems in the new budget
year.
This needs
attention and is being resolved immediately.
Conversion
to In-House Accounting
Prior to this
year, the DAPC utilized the services of an outside accountant to maintain
the Authority's financial records and to prepare checks. This responsibility
was assigned to Tennis Center staff under the direction of the Executive
Director as a cost cutting measure. The services of an outside accountant
established checks and balances which helped identify potential cash-flow
problems more quickly. This major change was made without the vote of
the Authority. The Authority should give serious consideration to immediately
engaging the services of an outside accountant.
Hiring Freeze
The DAPC voted
and approved a hiring freeze several months ago to insure that it stayed
within budget in FY 2003. The Executive Director has subsequently replaced
two full-time and two part-time employees in clear violation of the mandate.
There was never a vote by the Authority to make an exception or waive
the hiring freeze. I believe the workload of the departing employees could
have been absorbed by existing staff at considerable savings to the DAPC.
The hiring
freeze should be followed or action taken to rescind it.
Capital
Projects
There has been
no consolidated final report to the DAPC or to the public detailing the
exact expenditures and final cost related to the Amphitheater administrative
office/SCT building renovation (Approximately $200,000) or the Tennis
Center expansion project (Approximately $2,000,000). Members of the Authority
have been provided with a variety of somewhat disconnected change orders,
contracts, and partial lists of unpaid suppliers and sub-contractors.
It is very difficult for anyone to clearly understand the total financial
picture related to these capital expenditures.
This issue
is particularly important because of the controversy related to the cost
over-runs and the Authority's present inability to pay very large amounts
of money owed to Group VI and other companies. Some Authority members
were unaware of most of the cost over-runs until the project was complete
and the Mayor was quoted in the newspaper about cost over-runs.
The circumstances
that permitted these cost over-runs without vote of the Authority should
be better clarified and corrected.
Executive
Director's Compensation
The Executive
Director has been paid $30,000 annually. He is also paid a dollar amount
for each tennis lesson taught at the Tennis Center. He effectively determines
his compensation by controlling the number of tennis pros on staff and
promoting the teaching of lessons (e.g. Every ALTA team playing is required
as local facility policy to take lessons as a condition of playing at
the Tennis Center). Emphasis on instruction is good but it should no longer
be directly tied to the Executive Director's compensation. His annual
compensation in FY 2001 was $136,000, in FY 2002 was $139,000 and is projected
to be $130,000 in FY 2003.
A much more
appropriate compensation package and contract for employment has been
prepared and should be implemented as soon as possible if the Authority
elects to maintain the present management structure.
Co-mingling
of funds
Concern has
been expressed by some Authority members about the procedure for separating
revenue for court fees and other DAPC income from money due the Trading
Post (Tennis Pro Shop) from the sale of products such as balls, clothing
and rackets. There has been no accounting report, or other verifiable
indication that these transactions have been completely separated as requested.
I have no reason to believe there is wrong doing in connection with these
transactions; however, an improved reporting system is imperative to document
this needed separation of financial records between the Development Authority
and a private corporation, such as the Trading Post.
Rent for
the Trading Post (Tennis Pro Shop)
The Trading
Post, a privately owned corporation, is open seven days per week utilizing
DAPC employees to sell its products without paying rent for the space
or making contributions to pay for utilities. It is easy for critics to
draw the conclusion that the DAPC, which is partially funded with hotel-motel
tax is subsidizing the overhead of a privately owned company. This potential
problem could be solved by requiring the Trading Post to pay rent for
use of the facility. Also some degree of control and accountability should
be implemented in the utilization of DAPC employees as customer service
representatives to sell products on behalf of the Trading Post.
Elimination
of management committees
Management
Committees for the Amphitheater and the Tennis Center, each consisting
of two or more members of the Authority were created to oversee the operation
of the respective facilities in 2001. This organizational structure permitted
individual Authority members to narrow their focus with respect to direct
oversight while retaining their individual responsibilities on the seven
member board for economic development and broader overall supervision
of both venues. This structure was abandoned after one year and replaced
with a structure which in my view has not proven to be effective from
the standpoint of communication, financial management or oversight. The
need for change is obvious to those who have knowledge of the operation
of both facilities.
cc: City Council
Members
The Adidas contract
Exhibit "A"
Let this serve
as a five-year partnership agreement for Peachtree City Tennis Center/Development
Authority of Peachtree City ("PCTC") (February 18, 2002 - February
18, 2007). Please refer to the following outline:
The following
is what Adidas will receive from the PCTC:
· Designation
as official footwear and apparel sponsor of the PCTC.
· All
teaching staff shall wear exclusively Adidas apparel and footwear.
· Adidas
presence/branding on indoor center roof.
· A "black
diamond" signifying Adidas' corporate sponsorship.
· Official
apparel and footwear sponsor of the Goody's Products USTA Women's Championships
and title sponsorship of the Peach State Junior Tournament.
· One
Main Draw Challenger wildcard for singles in the Goody's Products USTA
Women's Championships to be mutually agreed upon by Peachtree City and
Adidas.
· One
qualifying singles wildcard in the Goody's Products USTA Women's Championships
to be mutually agreed upon by Peachtree City and Adidas.
· The
ability/option for Adidas to host at least one event each year at the
Peachtree City Tennis Center. This includes, but is not limited to:
- A professional
player exhibition featuring Adidas players.
Adidas
Invitational Collegiate Championships (every other year, begins in '02
then every other year after).
Adidas
Junior Team or Pro "aTTaCk" camps.
- Adidas Advisory
Staff meetings.
· 10 complimentary
rooms nights per year at a local hotel property.
· Official
apparel and footwear of the Peachtree City Junior Academy and USA Southern
Crescent Junior Team Tennis program.
· Adidas
will be profiled and have a logo/link on PCTC official website www.tenniscenter.net.
· Title
sponsorship of the fall junior tournament, here known as "Adidas
Fall Classic," held Oct./Nov. 2002-2007, for as long as the tournament
is held.
· PCTC
will guarantee Adidas sales of $60K the first year (once Pro Shop completed)
and increase this number by 10 percent each contract year as stated above.
[The following
section is handwritten.]
DAPC guarantees
sales to Adidas as follows:
2002 $60,000
+ 0 = $60,000
2003 60,000
+ 6,000 = 66,000
2004 66,000
+ 6,600 = 72,600
2005 72,600
+ 7,260 = 79,860
2006 79,869
+ 7986 = 87,846
Total Guaranteed
Sales $366,306 (per 5 year contract)
[The remainder
is typewritten.]
The following
is what Adidas will provide the Peachtree City Tennis Center:
· Adidas
Retail fixturing in new PCTC Pro Shop, best efforts for an Adidas "concept
shop." All fixturing shall be coordinated with PCTC architects.
· Best
efforts by Adidas to have Peachtree City host national Adidas Sales Meeting.
· Product
sponsorship for the Peachtree National Bank Women's Challenger valued
at $5000 (wholesale).
· Exclusive
outfitting of PCTC teaching staff for a total of (11), spots on the Adidas
Professional Advisory Staff, including Virgil Christian and two others
at level 1.
· The
ability for PCTC to buy product for the Junior Academy at twenty-five
(25) percent below wholesale.
· Adidas
shall purchase a corporate Membership at $10K/year which will be done
in product - this product will be used for ushers and staff at the Frederick
Brown Jr. Amphitheater, Adidas Fall Classic staff shirts, Peach State
Junior Tennis Classic or other NCAA/College events.
· Adidas
to provide T-shirts for each participant in the Peach State Junior Tennis
Classic and Adidas fall classic (Adidas to provide blanks and screen).
· Opportunity
to make an at-once 20 percent below wholesale apparel and footwear order
for the Challenger Event.
· Adidas
to provide mutually agreeable amount of travel bags for Junior Academy
(PCTC to embroider)
This serves
as the entire agreement between Peachtree City Tennis Center (PCTC) and
Adidas America. This agreement may be voided by Adidas if the Development
Authority of Peachtree City does not manage the PCTC. Should Adidas exercise
this option, thirty-day notice is required to be given by Adidas to PCTC.
[The document
is signed by two Adidas representatives, including the "Tennis Promotions
Manager," and by Virgil Christian as executive director, in addition
to a head professional.
Exhibit "B"
Development
Authority of Peachtree City
Audit Agenda
For the Year
Ended September 30, 2002
Accounting
and Related Matters (Continued)
5) Deferred
Revenue The Authority collects membership revenues in advance for quarterly
and annual paying members. These advance payments for memberships are
being recognized in revenue as the receipts of cash are collected. These
advance payments should be recognized as deferred revenue until the period
in which the revenue has been earned.
6) Recording
of Transactions
We noted during
our procedures that the Authority included transfers received from the
City and transfers to the City as net transactions within the Authority's
general ledger. These amounts should be shown in separate accounts for
financial reporting purposes.
7) Accounting
Policies
Overall, it
appears that the Authority still maintains its books on the cash basis
of accounting. To be in conformity with accounting principles generally
accepted in the United States of America, it is required that the Authority
maintain its general ledger on an accrual basis of accounting. This means
that revenue is recognized when it is earned and expenses are recognized
when a liability is incurred.
8) Knowledge
of Accounting
During or audit
for the year ended September 30, 2002 we noted that key members of management
did not contain an adequate level of knowledge and control over the accounting
function. We encountered several examples of this throughout the audit,
including not being furnished with amounts owed by the Authority as of
September 30, 2002 until after our audit fieldwork was complete. Management
should take more of a role in the accounting function of the Authority
and obtain the knowledge necessary to make management decisions.






Easy button Return it to long suffering taxpayers including those who have paid huge tabs to educate other people's kids…