The age of managed care ended
and the era of consumer-driven health care began on Wednesday, June 26,
2002.
That was the day the Internal
Revenue Service ruled that companies across America can liberate their
employees from the shackles of bureaucratic control over their health
insurance and create new health plans with incentives for employees to
be partners, not adversaries, in decisions about their health spending.
Now, any company, large or
small, has a green light to offer health plans based upon the structure
of Medical Savings Accounts.
Here's how they would work:
A company would put part of the money it had been spending on health insurance
premiums for an employee into a new tax-free account that the employee
could use to pay for routine medical bills. The company also would purchase
a catastrophic policy to cover the employee's major medical bills.
The key part of the IRS ruling
is in allowing employees to roll over any balance they have saved in their
health account from one year to the next. The money is theirs to keep,
even if they leave the company or retire. It stays tax-free as long as
it is spent on substantiated medical expenses.
This dramatically changes the
incentives in health spending. Workers, who in the past would make a doctor's
appointment for a sniffle or a stubbed toe, now may think twice, saving
doctors' visits for real medical needs.
During the heyday of managed
care in the 1990s, employers thought they had found the magic solution
to rising health insurance costs. They hired outside firms to oversee
employees' access to care and to negotiate lower payment rates with doctors,
labs, and hospitals.
But the incentives were all
wrong: Employees wanted more services and flexibility, and physicians
became angry and frustrated with micromanagement of their decisions. Employers
finally gave up the power struggle and relaxed the strings.
But partly as a result, health
insurance costs are soaring. Many companies expect their health insurance
costs to increase by 20 percent or more this year.
Clearly, something new is needed.
The IRS was asked last year
to interpret a provision in the tax code guiding employment-based health
insurance arrangements. Several wise officials correctly ruled that if
employers deposit money into health spending accounts for their employees,
it stays tax free and can be rolled over for future health expenses.
Some workers will choose to
stay with their current PPO or HMO, but others will opt instead for the
new accounts. Whichever route they choose, they will continue to have
insurance protection for major medical costs.
But if they choose the new
MSA-like accounts for routine and controllable expenses, employers and
employees will have the same goal: Spend wisely and save money. Employees
will see the money that they are spending on health care as real money
- their money - with dollars that have the same value as those they spend
on groceries, clothes, and housing.
In announcing the ruling, Treasury
Secretary Paul O'Neill said: "With this new guidance, we clear the
way for employers to adopt health plans with patient-directed features
so that employees have more choice and greater control over their health
care coverage."
Some workers already are eligible
for tax-favored Medical Savings Accounts, primarily the self-employed
and those working for companies with fewer than 50 employees.
But these first MSAs were created
in 1996 by an act of Congress, which put a mountain of rules and restrictions
on them that extinguished any chances of a viable market emerging.
The new plans, which the IRS
calls "Health Reimbursement Arrangements," won't be shaped by
politicians but by the marketplace.
There are issues to be resolved
about the new policies, involving incentives for preventive care and networks
of doctors that agree to lower rates in return for the direct payment.
But blessedly, companies, and not Congress, will be in charge of making
those decisions.
A number of major companies
are ready to offer this new product in their health insurance mix next
year but were waiting for the IRS to rule on whether or not the tax-free
rollover was legal. Many will be signing on the dotted line this summer
to make the new accounts available next year.
Fortune magazine reported recently
on the experience of a major health plan, Humana, in offering health accounts
to its own employees. Humana's internal health-insurance expenses were
expected to rise 19 percent this year, but because of these new consumer-directed
plans, may rise by only 4 percent.
A new era indeed is dawning.
[Grace-Marie Turner is an
adjunct scholar with the Georgia Public Policy Foundation and president
of the Galen Institute, www.galen.org, a not-for-profit public policy
research organization focusing on free-market health reform. The Foundation
is a nonpartisan, member-supported research and education organization
that promotes free markets, limited government and individual responsibility.
Its Internet address is www.gppf.org.]






Easy button Return it to long suffering taxpayers including those who have paid huge tabs to educate other people's kids…