There's an organization that
sends me e-mails every day or two addressing its concerns over immigration.
We in Fayette County are well
aware of the fact that there seem to be increasing numbers of people from
Mexico and other Central and South American Countries moving into the
U.S., both legally and not so legally.
Please don't read this as any
sort of stereotyping, but facts are facts: one need only ride by any construction
site or watch any landscaping crew at work to realize that our area has
become a popular destination for Hispanic migration.
I'm sure there are many of
these immigrants working in very highly skilled jobs as well, but they
aren't nearly as visible.
My anti-immigration e-mailers
insist that they're coming in too fast, and the situation is out of control.
They're taking jobs away from legal immigrants and U.S. citizens, and
they're going to overwhelm our government services.
Now the president wants to
allow all the illegal aliens currently living here to earn the right to
come out of the closet and stay here permanently. People who were worried
before are now frantic.
I'm not frantic. I'm waiting
to see how the president proposes to get through the logistical nightmare
of simply getting all of the paperwork done. And I'm curious about whether
the State Department is expecting an amnesty announcement to generate
a stampede at the border as people try to cross it in time to be included
in the amnesty.
But the biggest question I
have for President Bush is: "What comes next?"
Currently, we don't seem to
have a very coherent or cohesive immigration policy.
As my German friend has pointed
out to me, we give Europeans and Africans a hard time if they want to
come here ... sometimes it takes years to get visas. Yet our neighbors
to the south come over in droves.
Will this amnesty apply only
to Mexicans, only to Hispanics, or to all illegal aliens?
After the amnesty, will we
take measures to slam the southern borders shut? Will we get mean about
it ... shoot people trying to get in the way East German soldiers used
to shoot people trying to get out?
If not, I can't see any way
we're going to prevent even greater numbers from coming in, in hopes of
another amnesty in the future.
But if so, we've kind of lost
sight of that whole "Give us your tired, poor, etc." concept.
As an aside, although this
is really not a liberal or conservative issue, it occurs to me to wonder
how liberal thinking deals with this.
On the one hand, you want to
be openhearted about giving as many people as possible a shot at the American
dream (although if you keep driving taxes higher and higher there won't
be an American dream).
On the other hand, large numbers
of people moving quickly into a country, or a community, can be pretty
damaging to the environment. You have to cut down more trees, and give
them less time to grow back before you have to cut down still more. You
have to build more housing and more businesses to serve that housing,
and all of that takes up pervious surface and contributes to storm water
runoff problems, not to mention pollution of air, soil and water.
Anyway, I think most of us
can agree, liberal or conservative, that we need a well-thought-out plan
for dealing with immigration something fair to both current citizens and
potential citizens, yet something that slows down the flow enough that
the impact doesn't rock us too much.
I don't think we have that
right now, and I'm expecting the Bush Administration to give it to us.
Soon would be nice.






Easy button Return it to long suffering taxpayers including those who have paid huge tabs to educate other people's kids…