Give Thanks and Avoid Uncle Bill

Share this Post
Views 131 | Comments 0
A multigenerational family shares a Thanksgiving dinner with a roast turkey at a candlelit table.

Give Thanks and Avoid Uncle Bill

A multigenerational family shares a Thanksgiving dinner with a roast turkey at a candlelit table.
Share this Post
Views 131 | Comments 0

Thanksgiving comes in many flavors: praise for God’s blessings, three NFL games in a row, or simply the prospect of a four-day weekend. We might be just as grateful for Aunt Grace bringing her signature pecan pie as for Uncle Bill leaving his latest conspiracy at home.

Whether God appreciates our thanks is a matter of faith. How our neighbors receive it is something researchers can test. The answer is more surprising than you might think.

Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley ran a series of experiments comparing how people expected their thank-you letters to be received with how recipients actually felt. They asked participants to write letters expressing gratitude to people who had positively affected their lives. Before delivering the letters, the writers predicted how the recipients would react.

The letter writers were poor prognosticators. They consistently underestimated how happy the recipients would be, overestimated how awkward the recipients would feel, and underestimated how much the recipients would be surprised by the specific reason for the gratitude.

The writers worried too much about how their thanks would land and too little about the pleasure they might give. Translation: we spend far more time looking in the mirror than out the window.

Frankly, I’d be grateful to know how the researchers persuaded participants to put away their cellphones long enough to write those letters in the first place. That may be the most impressive finding of all.

At the risk of sounding like a Ginsu knife commercial, wait, there’s more. A simple thank-you may change our behavior. Adam Grant and Francesca Gino found that people who received expressions of gratitude subsequently became more willing to help—not just the person who thanked them, but other people as well. In one field experiment, university fundraisers who received expressions of gratitude from their manager made more fundraising calls.

Grant and Gino reported that the operative mechanism wasn’t simply improved mood or increased confidence. Rather, they experienced a heightened sense of social worth: their contributions mattered to someone. The next time a volunteer calls to ask for a donation, try thanking them for their time—you might inadvertently boost their quota.

Making someone feel appreciated is one thing. Turning gratitude into a personal happiness program is another. A 2025 meta-analysis covering 145 studies on gratitude found that gratitude exercises produced small average improvements in well-being—not a ticket to cloud nine. Still not bad for penning a few sentences.

So here’s my modest proposal. Before the turkey is carved, write three sentences to someone who made your year a little better. Name the specific thing they did, since that’s the part the research says surprises people. Skip the cursive and the greeting-card poetry. If it takes longer than the pie takes to cool, you’re overthinking it.

Maybe it’ll get paid forward, but don’t expect magic. Making someone feel that their kindness mattered is enough. And be sure to thank God if you avoid getting cornered by Uncle Bill.

Dave Aycock


Dave Aycock

Dr. David Aycock is a recently retired psychologist and long-time resident of Fayette County. He has written two books and many journal articles, and, when not entertaining his two granddaughters, he enjoys looking at life from quirky angles.

Stay Up-to-Date on What’s Fun and Important in Fayette

Newsletter







Latest Comments

VIEW ALL
The Turkey on the Counter: Normal Aging or Time ...

Caregivers Need Care Too
Medicare and Social(ism) Security
Almost…
Break a Leg
Newsletter







Scroll to Top