A Wicked review from Fayette County superfan: Comparing the stage show and new movie

0
1657
This photo of me (Claire Kaufman) was taken during the 20th Anniversary Celebration of Wicked at the Gershwin Theatre in New York City, where the Tony Award-winning musical first premiered in 2003

As a Fayette County resident who appreciates the artistic contributions of Trillith Studios, I’m excited to share my thoughts on Wicked, one of my favorite shows. Having seen the musical live in multiple cities, including with the original Broadway cast, I’ve had the chance to enjoy both the stage version and the new movie adaptation. Each offers something unique, providing a different perspective on this beloved story.

A key strength of the movie is the performances of the lead actresses. Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande shine as Elphaba and Glinda, with great chemistry and powerful vocals. The film also offers a deeper look at Elphaba’s backstory, exploring her childhood in a way the stage production doesn’t. This added depth helps viewers better understand her motivations and makes her character more relatable.

The visual format of the film also enhances the experience. Close-up shots reveal subtle emotional details in the actors’ performances that may be missed in a live show, especially for those sitting far from the stage. Additionally, the actors sing live on set, which highlights their impressive vocal talent and dedication.

The movie also takes full advantage of advanced technology. For example, using a real goat to portray Dr. Dillamond, rather than a person in a costume, adds a sense of realism to the story. Similarly, the flying monkeys are shown actually flying and look like real monkeys, which is a significant improvement over the makeup and effects used in the stage production. The film’s special effects bring the magical world of Oz to life in ways that are difficult to replicate on stage, creating a fully immersive visual experience.

That said, the live theater experience of Wicked has its own magic. The energy of a live performance, with real-time music and audience interaction, creates an atmosphere that can’t be replicated on screen. The immediate connection between performers and the audience adds excitement and emotion that makes theater unique.

It’s also important to note that the movie is only part one of the story, ending at the musical’s intermission. This creates a cliffhanger, leaving viewers eager for part two, which will be released in November 2025. The first movie installment introduces exciting plot twists and deeper character development, revealing that some characters who initially seem villainous are more complex and even redeeming.

When comparing the musical to the movie, it’s important to recognize that they offer different experiences. The stage show thrives on the energy of the live audience, while the film uses cinematic techniques like close-ups and visual storytelling to explore the characters’ emotions in ways the stage production can’t. Both versions have their strengths, and I recommend experiencing both to get a fuller understanding of Wicked.

In conclusion, comparing the Wicked movie and stage musical isn’t easy, as both offer distinct and complementary takes on the story. Whether you see the show live at Atlanta’s Fox Theatre or watch the movie at Cinemark Tinseltown 17 in Fayetteville or NCG in Sharpsburg, the themes of self-empowerment, acceptance, and embracing our differences resonate with audiences worldwide. No matter the format, Wicked continues to captivate and inspire, reminding us to embrace who we are and recognize our own power.

This review is dedicated to my Grandma Bobby, who took me to see Wicked with the original Broadway cast. That experience was a turning point for me, and since then, my perspective on life has truly been “changed for good.” Her love for the arts and her belief in the power of storytelling will forever be a part of how I view the world.